Yes, judge away, I have so far watched four seasons of
Jon & Kate Plus 8. It's a very interesting show because in a short few years, the entire mission statement of the show changed from boasting the benefits of a large family (in the vein of
17 Kids and Counting) to simply watching in horror as two human beings crumble into the very worst versions of themselves under the stress of the aforementioned large family.
Believe it or not, there are lessons to be learned from the show. Not just "be content with what you have," nor the dangers of fertility treatments resulting in multiple pregnancies. Relationship lessons. Oh yes.
Jon and Kate are victims of the "traditional" family that is propagandized as the ideal in middle America, which simply cannot work in a modern world. Or at least, not with 6 infants. Jon, as the husband, is told he must provide for his family monetarily. And Kate, with the children, is to be the stay-at-home mother who handles the domestic chores. However, this model will crumble under the pressure of eight children under the age of 5. More specifically, half a dozen infants. Kate has been destroyed by the pressures at home, and Jon is oblivious to this because he is focused on his "man's work." But that much can be obvious.
As parents, they both attempt to fulfill different roles. Jon is feebly attempting to be the children's friend, while he is truly afraid of children and uncomfortable relating to them. Kate wants to be the children's taskmaster, while she is uncomfortable relating to the children. They are not united on how they want to approach parenting, and thus are constantly in conflict. And when Kate tries to have fun with the children, Jon balks at her stepping into his role and not having someone in control, and gets nervous and starts an argument. You can learn a lot about how NOT to be a parent from the show. Especially the way they approach their children as an obligation and a burden.
But something you realize only after watching 75 episodes (yes, I'm on episode 75, thank you for reminding me, Netflix) is that they don't really love each other. Obviously, we all know that the series will end in infidelity and acrimonious divorce, but they didn't have to travel down a long road, or have 8 children together, to get there. From the very beginning, Jon marries Kate because it is what he is expected to do. As a mid-twenties-30-something-year-old, he is expected to marry a woman, put a roof over her head, sire her children, and build her storage units. He does this, but he is still unhappy. Middle America is running 20 years behind on societal understanding, so they don't realize that the 1950's white picket fence dream doesn't guarantee happiness, and this results in divorce (as many of our parents and our parents' parents already learned). Kate, on the other hand, is a little more complicated. She is either genuinely in love with Jon, or she is genuinely in love with the
idea of Jon (and the white picket fence). If the latter is true, then it explains why she fights so hard to maintain the idea that everything is fine, and why she is so desperate to control her family and her husband and her life through her ridiculous micromanaging. But that's a little too easy. In their interviews, she sometimes looks at him as though she really does love him...
sometimes. Her tragedy could be that she fell in love with a man, and signed her life away to him, before she realized he is not who she thought he was. Now she is stuck, and unhappy, and desperate to corral her life and her kids into the shape of what she wanted all along. Meanwhile, though she resents Jon and is disappointed in him, she loves the memory of him and wants him to be the young man who had the potential to turn into the knight in shining armor she expected.
What hoped to be a praise of traditional values in a modern world dissolves into an uncomfortable and deeply sad real-life
Revolutionary Road. Which should hopefully demonstrate that traditional values need to evolve and adapt to our modern needs and sensibilities. But maybe not. If you choose to learn from
Jon & Kate Plus 8, rather than condemn them, the truth is much scarier than you thought it would be.